Short Wave: Mirror, Mirror, On The Wall - Can You Reveal An Animal's Inner World At All?

Daniel Povinelli was in high school when he first read about a clever experiment, published in 1970, that showed chimpanzees—but not monkeys–can recognize themselves in mirrors.

“I bought into the story of mirrors and self-recognition hook, line, and sinker,” he recalls. “Because it is a compelling story.”

All it took was a simple mirror, or so the story went, to reveal that our close chimpanzee relatives are self-aware, with the same kind of basic self-concept that humans have.

“The idea that there are other creatures out there for whom we can only access their mental states, their self-consciousness, through the trick of a mirror was somehow just deeply inviting,” recalls Povinelli, now a scientist with the University of Louisiana at Lafayette.

He ended up devoting years of his life to studying mirrors and higher-order consciousness. As a result, he now has a much different view on what animals may be doing as they study their own reflections—but says after a half-century, the public seems stuck on the scientific tale that drew him in as a teenager.

 

Short Wave Podcast

It’s science for everyone, using a lot of creativity and a little humor. Join host Maddie Sofia for science on a different wavelength.


Science Topics
Biology, Zoology
Animals
Chimpanzees, Monkeys
Middle School, High School
7th Grade, 8th Grade, 9th Grade, 10th Grade, 11th Grade, 12th Grade, Adults

What are you looking for?

Organization

Short Wave (NPR)

Website URL

Type of Resource

Podcast

Assigned Categories